She Who Is Ignorant
Guest
|
Post by She Who Is Ignorant on Oct 8, 2006 14:09:53 GMT
Hi!  I was cruising around, found this site, and was hopping to some opinions, if you don't mind. It's a parody Harry Potter rpg. So a play-by-post character driven rpg, but in a parody universe. All comments are welcome, don't hold back! I really want to get this as good as possible! www.bravelyignorant.proboards101.com |
|
|
|
Post by *~Shadow~* on Oct 8, 2006 22:41:02 GMT
Layout(graphics)
score: 7/10
comment: backround is kinda plain. Also you dont have a banner saying the name of you forum.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
customization
score: 2/10
comment: you guys really didnt change anything. From what i can see. everything is red or black. Also your icons are the ones that come with proboards instead you should try making your own or requesting the from some where.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
staff/members
score: 9/10
comment: You should change the colors of staff members so that people can see who is and isnt one. But other than that the staff looks likes its been doing its job.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
other comments/overall
score: 6/10
comment: just change a couple of those things and as far as im concerned and you'll be good to go. Also i like that you are using creativity. Most forums are basic copies of other forums but your forum is really original.
|
|
She Who Is Ignorant
Guest
|
Post by She Who Is Ignorant on Oct 10, 2006 15:12:55 GMT
Thanks very much for your comments! I really appreciate it! Layout: *is confused* I do have a banner with the forum name... Customization: I'm just leaning what's available and how to do it now! I've started making icons - I think they're cute, but I'm only half way there, there are so many! But the red and black thing is intentional - nice and simply, because I want to draw the focus to the content. Staff: I thought of changing colours, but I decided not to - we don't want to put ourselves above our other members. But thankyou - we're really trying hard! Overall: Thanks for saying it's original! That's the most important thingto me, and I'm really glad you think so!  Thanks so much for your comments! |
|
|
|
Post by chester71 on Oct 11, 2006 0:35:30 GMT
I'm sure that his browser didn't load the banner. I see that you do. Its an interesting banner. I don't like banners that are not rectangular but some people might so i give your banner 8/10 because I really like how you(or someone else) drew the little cartoon I like them. Very good board overall, it could use some work tho. If you even need some help with forum making and all that junk, drop by and post it and we will help you as much as we can. Logan |
|
|
|
Post by *~Shadow~* on Oct 13, 2006 22:31:46 GMT
Thanks very much for your comments! I really appreciate it! Layout: *is confused* I do have a banner with the forum name... Overall: Thanks for saying it's original! That's the most important thingto me, and I'm really glad you think so! Thanks so much for your comments! Oh i see it now. sorry about that. And your welcome for all comment. |
|
Orif
NooB Advertiser
Posts: 46
|
Post by Orif on Dec 20, 2006 15:34:33 GMT
THREAD LOCKED
This thread was locked due to spam rates.
|
|
