Boards/Categories/Content:- Not bad. If it were my forum, I would probably have a few less boards but its not a big problem. The board that hasnt been replied to since January 1st - perhaps you could do something about it? It pulls down the activity of the forum overall, which looks pretty good until you see that board. Perhaps merge the whole board with another or as a sub-board.
- This is just a personal opinion. I would put the RPG talk category last and The RPG category in the middle.
Ranking: 8/10
-----------------------------------------------
Graphics- The on and off icons are okay but nothing great. Try something else, perhaps a resized version of the arrows in the background image.
- The menu buttons are simple but effective, job well done.
- The image you use for the voting promotion of the site isnt great. I dont like the way
Vote for this site touched the top left hand corner sides of the image. The font and colour used for
RPG Host makes it difficult to read. Other than that, its okay.
Ranking: 6/10
----------------------------------------------
Coding:- The re-size forum width code really benefits the presentation of your forum.
- In your advanced info centre, there is a slight glitch. Apparantly, you have a total of 0 members. I think that might be a lie
If you dont know how to fix this, request code support in a suitable place online.
- Some shoutboxes I feel can look messy on forums, but yours does not.
- The RPG Database table code you have used looks good, so much better than a news fader.
- The category splitter code works wonderfully with the skin.
Ranking: 8/10
Skin:- The colours used are lovely, they work well together, they arent too bright etc. Very well done.
- The window one, therefore the board highlight colour, looks great.
- The gradients give the forum a very cool and smooth feel, complimenting the skin. The text colour used for the category titles is slightly hard to read though against the gradient colour.
- The background is good, but not completely topical imo. I love the white part in the centre (which works very well with the category splitter) and the rest is pretty good as well, but the whole thing looks very modern.
Ranking: 8/10
----------------------------------------------
Any additional information:- I dislike the contrast between the two logo images used. The banner looks modern, whereas the voting promotional image used in the table does not.
Overall:Good looking forum, you deserve the activity you have and more
Ranking: 8/10Chaz
