|
|
Post by biznick on Oct 22, 2007 20:57:16 GMT
What do you wanna talk about? Music, sports, anime? Like taking polls, quizzes and surveys? Are you a Masta-Debator? S.O.B. offers many topics to discuss, the ULTIMATE GENERAL/RANDOM FORUM of proboards!! its time to RISE against BOREDOM!!! Are you ready? boredomsociety.proboards50.com |
|
|
|
Post by Jm3z on Feb 17, 2008 19:49:49 GMT
Apologies for the long wait.
Boards/Categories/Content: all of the boards on the main page have a fair few posts in which is good for drawing members in. I’m not sure that separate categories are needed for Random Fun and Community; I think that they could come under the same heading and some boards could be made sub-boards instead. Umm one small thing; in the main table there is a list of the top 5 posters, making each into a link to their profile would be better for quick viewing.
Ranking: [glow=orange,2,300]7/10[/glow]
-----------------------------------------------
Graphics: You could use some footer images as well as headers for each category (would work well with category splitter – see coding below). Main banner works well with the forum however I’m not sure that the pixel – effect style is working, the banner could be made simpler and would make more impact; maybe make the text a little bigger also.
Ranking: [glow=orange,2,300]6/10[/glow]
----------------------------------------------
Coding: A category separator might be a good idea as they look a little cramped together at the moment. Could change affiliates table to a random one as scrolling affiliates can look a little tacky. The code for the table for member info whilst viewing your profile is a good one, makes it look unique.
Ranking: [glow=orange,2,300]7/10[/glow]
----------------------------------------------
Skin: Colour scheme is well thought out and effective, colours do not clash anywhere and compliment each other. You could really do with making some new menu icons as the current ones look as if no attention has been paid to them. The default icons do not go well with the skin, the profile icons etc. could be changed (however this is a lengthy job due to the number of them). I can’t tell if the posts page icons are different as a guest but if they have not been changed to match the skin either then it could be a good idea.
Ranking: [glow=orange,2,300]7/10[/glow]
----------------------------------------------
Any additional information: There is a huge number of posts for the number of members; fantastic work on building a strong community!
Overall:
The forum has a very strong community basis which I would imagine is growing quickly and I should imagine it will keep doing. However, the forum is based mainly around chat, and provides little other service, so it will only attract certain types of members, if this is the aim of the forum then it is not a problem but it could prevent the forum from growing to its full potential.
Overall Ranking: [glow=LimeGreen,2,300]7/10[/glow]
|
|
